From Bloody Sunday to Bloody Monday – oppressors use the same old lies.

This mornings act of piracy and murder by the military wing of the state of Israel has rightly provoked outrage across the world. The Gaza freedom flotilla was an unarmed civilian humanitarian aid convoy in international waters. Yet the Israeli state propaganda (hasbara) machine is trying to construct its media spin, to justify this atrocity – they are claiming that the human rights activists were ‘Hamas terrorists’ who attacked first! This is despite the fact that the people on board the ship were an international collection of activists consisting of Jews, Muslims, Christians and others, and included citizens of America, Britain, Turkey, Israel and many more countries. On board were respected peace and human rights activists, plus parliamentarians and journalists, all attempting to bring aid to Gaza, to highlight the injustice of Israel’s blockade of Gaza which the UN has said is leading to poverty, hunger and death.

But we should beware that all states who repress a population construct a defensive wall of lies, propaganda and spin. Here in Britain we were kept in ignorance about the behavior of the british state in the north of Ireland for years. In the 1972 ‘Bloody Sunday’ massacre British troops opened fire on a civil rights demonstration. 14 people were killed. Eyewitnesses, including British and Irish journalists maintain that the soldiers fired into an unarmed crowd, or were aiming at fleeing people and those tending the wounded. After official enquiries, this is now the accepted story. Yet at the time, and for some years after, the state propaganda machine said otherwise. The British Home Secretary, speaking the next day in the House of Commons, put forward the army propaganda position that the British paratroopers had reacted to the gun and nail bomb attacks from suspected IRA members. The media spun this lie to the British public.

The same pattern can be seen in the Sharpeville massacre in Apartheid South Africa in 1960, where the South African police opened fire on a crowd of black civil rights protesters, killing 69 people. Back then, the Apartheid state and media claimed that the police were defending themselves from ‘black violence’.

The majority of White South Africans believed in the propaganda after Sharpeville, just as the majority of the British public were taken in by the propaganda after Bloody Sunday. After todays Gaza aid ship massacre, plenty of Israelis (and the international fellow travelers and apologists for Israeli state policy) will believe the propaganda as well.

This is the case everywhere. While tens of thousands of Turkish people are rightly taking to the streets in anger at the Israeli states persecution of the Palestinians, many Turks will remain in ignorance about their own states appalling treatment of the Kurdish people. Those who live inside a state that is repressing another people are the last to learn the truth.

But today, those outside the Israeli state / media bubble – i.e. the rest of the world – have seen the reality that Israel is a rouge state, out of control. Todays massacre will be a turning point, just as Sharpeville and Bloody Sunday were. Even though it took many more bloody decades of struggle for truth and justice to surface (still incompletely), it is clear that the current status quo in the middle east cannot last forever. Viva Palestina!

Another truth must surface. As Marx once said of Britain and Ireland: “A nation that oppresses another can never itself be free”.

Shalom Aleichem! שָׁלוֹם עֲלֵיכֶם / Salaam-Alaikum السلام عليكم / Peace be upon you

Free Gaza and Palestine

Free Gaza and Palestine



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “From Bloody Sunday to Bloody Monday – oppressors use the same old lies.

  1. Jez

    “Israeli state propaganda machine is trying to construct its media spin”

    Hardly necessary when the BBC is doing such a good job of getting the Israeli state view across. The majority of the quotes on their website are from Israeli government/IDF sources. It’s fucking outrageous. the first lines are –

    “Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu has expressed regret after at least nine people died when troops stormed ships trying to break the Gaza blockade.

    But he said soldiers had been defending themselves after they were “clubbed, beaten and stabbed”.”

    Its a boycott of the BBC not just Israel thats needed.

  2. anon

    The brain dead soldier who was thrown off the deck would agree with you.

    The soldier shot in the stomach and knee would also agree that his comrades had no right to open fire. After all, the other activists were just stomping his head like a melon, they seamed to be knowing what they were doing.

  3. barrykade

    Yes, “anon” it is tragic that these soldiers were sent in on a reckless night time, illegal commando raid in international waters, descending out of the sky from a helicopter where a tragedy was bound to happen. Both Soldiers and civilians were bound to be hurt. How stupid. Are anti-Israel propagandists in charge of IDF operations, do you think? They certainly have delivered a propaganda coup for their enemies.
    A normal state would wait until the convoy was out of international waters, and would send the coastguard in broad daylight. A night time commando raid?! Bloody fools!

    However, while you are shedding your tears, remind yourself again. It was the Israeli soldiers who attacked the ship – at night – in international waters. And it was the Israeli soldiers who had the guns – not the civilians. And it was the civilians who have died and been injured in large amounts. I had three friends from the UK peace movement on those ships. I have still to hear if they are alive, or injured, or OK. These friends are committed to peace and human rights, and are some of the best people I have met.

    But you will probably choose to ignore anything that contradicts your worldview, as I guess you are a true believer in the Israeli states agenda. I expect you support the illegal occupations of Gaza and the West Bank as well? I expect you can perform any amount of mental gymnastics to support the oppression of the Palestinians.

    Israel is loosing support everywhere. Years ago, half of my friends were sympathetic to Israel – visiting Kibbutzes, or partying in Tel Aviv. Now we will all be attending protests against the Israeli states atrocities this week. Every town in Britain is seeing a wave of protest. Its great! Goodbye and good luck, “anon”.

    Shalom Aleichem! שָׁלוֹם עֲלֵיכֶם / Salaam-Alaikum السلام عليكم / Peace be upon you

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s